What does a well-known writer do when she gets writer's block? She goes on vacation. That is exactly what Poppy Monroe does when she finds a brochure for a cabin in the White Mountains of Arizona in the quaint town of Greer. She is surprised to find her cabin has been overbooked and is sharing it with a handsome chef. What could be worse than having to share a rental with a total stranger? Poppy finds just that out when her family unexpectedly shows up, surprising her for Christmas. Mishaps ensue, family drama, and an incident which may bring Poppy's relationship to an end just as it begins. Not only that, but the Monroe sisters realize it took being apart to finally bring them together. Can Poppy overcome her writer's block or will her bad luck continue? Will she find love just to have to let it go? Can old and new wounds be mended, and will love conquer all?